Children's Hospital is part of the UPMC family.
Be safe anytime, anywhere.
To find a pediatrician or pediatric specialist, please call 412-692-7337 or search our directory.
A resource for our network of referring physicians.
For more information about research, please call our main office at 412-692-6438.
Ranked #8 Nationally by U.S. News & World Report.
Alejandro Hoberman, MD, chief of the Division of General Academic Pediatrics and president of Children’s Community Pediatrics, has contributed research on urinary tract infections and acute otitis media, and in this episode, the focus is on the ears. He discusses the role of antibiotics, duration of treatment, resistance, adverse outcomes, allergies, and more. Dr. Hoberman also talks about the role that new technologies and multimedia tools play in treatment and discussions with parents.
View the transcript for this podcast (PDF)
Speaker 1: This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only and is not to be
considered medical advice for any particular patient. Clinicians must rely on
their own informed clinical judgements when making recommendations for
their patients. Patients in need of medical advice should consult their personal
Carolyn Coyne: From UPMC Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh, welcome to That's Pediatrics. I'm Carolyn Coyne. I'm a basic scientist in the Division of Pediatric Infectious
Brian Martin: And I'm Brian Martin. I'm Vice President of Medical Affairs here at Children's.
Brian Martin: For today's episode, we welcome Alejandro Hoberman . Dr. Hoberman is the
President of Children's Community Pediatrics and also the Chief of the Division
of General Academic Pediatrics here at Children's. His studies focus on acute
otitis media in young children, including a landmark trial published in the New
England Journal of Medicine which demonstrated that the reduction of duration
of antibiotics does more harm than good when treating ear infections in young
children. Welcome, Dr. Hoberman.
Carolyn Coyne: Thanks for joining us, Alejandro.
Alejandro Hoberman: Thank you.
Carolyn Coyne: So let's talk about ears. I have a son at home with an ear infection as we speak
and so I would like for you to tell us a little bit about your journey into how you
chose the discipline that you work on and then also of course tell us a little bit
about your research.
Alejandro Hoberman: So I was 26 I think and I was at Children's Hospital in Buenos Aires, Argentina
and I was the only crazy person with a pneumatic otoscope trying to teach
myself how to do a pneumatic otoscopy and remove the eardrums, which was
described from the journals I was reading in those days. Jack Paradise here in
Pittsburgh and Ellen Wald, then Charlie Bluestone was the one who most of the
papers were from. I was excited about trying to learn how to do this, and I
wrote to Jack and very interesting he sent me a telegram saying that some
peoples coming to Children's Hospital in Buenos Aires and he would interview
me there and invited me to interview with Allan Drash in Buenos Aires, who was
the head of endocrinology here in that day.
Alejandro Hoberman: Then I came for fellowship and fellowship meant, I did know that when I was
there, that I needed to do my own research studies. There you go, Jack Paradise
and Ken Rogers made two mentors started pushing me like crazy, which is the
project you're going to be working on over the next two years. I ended up
working in multiple projects. I ended up doing work on urinary tract infections
and otitis media and I have always had that problem in my life, I was a little
unfocused. I was focused on two different areas, I continue that over the years.
Alejandro Hoberman: Sylvan Stool was another otolaryngologist here in those days and Sylvan, who
was a pediatrician before being an otolaryngologist, had this huge cart with a
big Sony TV, ones they have in the O.R, and Zeno light source and a
otoendoscope and he said "You can do a lot more good with this than we can in
otolaryngology, so why don't you take it and use it to teach the residents?" So
we started gathering images, videos, and trying to use those in training
Alejandro Hoberman: Then, we opened up an ear check clinic to see children on follow-up after an ear
infection. Then, we developed multimedia tools and then we got a grant from
the CDC to teach pediatricians how to do a diagnosis of acute otitis media and
distinguish it from otitis media with effusion and no effusion, then we got
embarked on every single development on a new antibiotic that was coming in
the market in the '90's and 2000's. Then, about 18 years ago, no more
antibiotics had been approved for upper respiratory infections since then. I
think 2003 or four was the last one that was approved. Everything else since has
not been resulted in approval by FDA, so we got embarked on other studies
Brian Martin: How has that change in the antibiotic development affected your pathway and
the conversation in both your research life and also with your general pediatric
Alejandro Hoberman: In my research life, I departed from being involved in a lot of, what I used to
think of it as Colgate research, like toothpaste research, determining whether
Colgate was better than Crest and so forth, and I got involved in trying to
determine what or when do really need to use antibiotics. So we did a study
which we looked at kids with bronchiolitis and we tried to determine okay, do
they have an ear infection? If they have an ear infection are they viral or
bacterial, and we tap the ears of those thirty-some kids, and we basically found
that all had bacterial acute otitis media. So then we started thinking about we
need to do a randomized placebo control study to try to determine the benefit
antimicrobial treatment. In the mid-2000's, 2004 or five, we got funded by NIH
to do a randomized placebo control study and that one we published in 2011 in
the Journal of Medicine. We showed that by providing antimicrobial treatment
not only resulted in substantial less treatment failures, but also there was
improvement with regards to symptoms. In order to show both, that the
abscess, the bulging ear drum, was likely to be gone if you received the proper
antibiotic but also the child got better faster.
Alejandro Hoberman: We went on to how long do we have to treat? Do we need to treat the 10 days
of treatment? The goal is to use the minimal amount that you need for any kind
of condition, and we didn't know 10 days were needed. A lot of folks were
reporting about using five days of treatment, and then we went back to the NIH
and got funded to compare five versus 10 days on a blood agency analysis that
took us many years to do. We randomized there 520 children, the goal was 600
but they stopped us early because they thought we answered the question, so
they didn't want us to randomize anybody else. We showed that 10 days made
a difference compared to five days. Five days resulted in twice as many
treatment failures, so the advice Carolyn to you and your son, is ten days
complete the treatment because the likelihood of 5 A.M bulging ear drum's
going to be a lot less.
Carolyn Coyne: I'm obviously into infectious diseases, so this is something I care a lot about and
think a lot about and of course this idea of antimicrobial resistance and what a
problem this is just globally in many, many aspects of healthcare. I'm wondering
if you could talk a little bit about that, obviously a big concern is you're
discussing what you mentioned before which is viral versus bacterial infections,
how you distinguish those, and what the adverse outcomes can be if you
prescribe antibiotics for obviously an unnecessary viral infection.
Alejandro Hoberman: You're absolutely correct. I think the key point is when do you prescribe the
antibiotic? It's once you do have a bulging ear drum. The middle ear is the only
place in the body where you can actually see the abscess. You cannot see in the
larynx, you cannot see in the sinuses, you can see it with the otoscope in the
middle ear. You can determine outcome by looking at the abscess and seeing if
it’s gone or not. I would say we can do a lot more in decreasing the emergence
of bacteria resistance by actually diagnosing the condition accurately. Making
the effort to distinguish those who are just having little bit of fluid that doesn't
need to be treated, that doesn't cause any harm, my mentor Jack Paradise
showed that it doesn't make you less smarter to have fluid in the ear and it
doesn't make you talk slower if you have fluid in the ear. We know that basically
we don't do much about middle ear fluid, but if it's infected and it's an abscess
and it's bulging, those children we must treat. Particularly, if they're young.
Alejandro Hoberman: The American Academy of Pediatrics had the guideline committee, I was part of
that committee we had huge debates. If you focus on the children under age
two, who are the ones that are most likely, that's where the peak incidents of
otitis media is between six months and 24 months, those benefit from
antimicrobial therapy. Then, using the right antimicrobial therapy is important
to use amoxacillin the guidelines are very clear on that amoxicillin-clavulanate,
when that fails, then cefuroxime, there is no room for azithromycin, there is no
room for Ceftin, there's no room for those medications unless in the truly
penicillin allergic patient who we know, but not that many. We label a lot of
children as having penicillin allergies, but they not always have penicillin
Brian Martin: I'd like to come back to the sensitivity and diagnoses which you just spoke of,
can you share with us some work which you're currently doing that's
complimentary to your work in terms of assisting those who diagnose middle
ear disease and improving the quality of our diagnosis which obviously feeds
downstream to our therapy.
Alejandro Hoberman: Sure. I'm getting to the point after having done 20 years of developing
multimedia tools, web base, CDs, write chapters, and participating guideline
committees, and write about these things. Sometimes we get to a ceiling effect
of how good could we be at diagnosing otitis media. I would say when we're
referred patients from practices or from a urgent care centers, emergency
departments sometimes too, who are diagnosed with having an ear infection.
Many times they don't have an ear infection, they just have fluid in the middle
ear. The variability in the diagnose for otitis media, of acute otitis media, is high.
Alejandro Hoberman: We'd like to try to assist and develop diagnostic aids and over the last few years,
I've been working with folks that were coming out of university. My colleague,
Jelena Kovacevic, was the head of Electrical and Computer Engineering at CMU
and now actually she just departed and she's now the dean of Computer
Engineering at NYU. She and I are still collaborating and she is the queen of
classification algorithms, she taught me that we can teach computers how to do
the same things that we do in our minds when we diagnose otitis media. Later,
she and I, and others and Jack Paradise have worked on developing algorithmic
thinking on how we think when we go look at an ear drum. The key point is is
there a bulge or no, if there is bulging we're done, we don't need more things. If
there's no bulging, if there is opacity of the ear drum, it could be middle ear
effusion, those are the things that we consider in general. If not, it's a normal
Alejandro Hoberman: The American Academy pushed to even make on the latest guidelines from
2013, that the right ear drum does not constitute sufficient to diagnose acute
otitis media. So acute otitis media could give you a right ear drum, unilateral,
doesn't have to be bilateral, and we don't treat those patients. If we were strict
to treating those who are truly having a bulging ear drum, we could do a lot of
good and decrease the likelihood of resistance.
Alejandro Hoberman: Going back to Jelena, the engineers are the ones that designed this systems that
classify blood cells or tumor cells, or whatever it is. She applied the vocabulary
and the grammar that we think once we look at ear drums to the way they
interpret images. We created system that actually creates a automatic
segmentation of the ear drum, removing the ear canal, and uses eight additional
features that actually classifies them into three categories: normal, middle ear
effusion otitis media with effusion, or acute otitis media. The system is close to
90% accurate. We compare that with what we get with pediatricians and
unusual variabilities at about 80% the best. The system works very well. We're
now doing video captures, we developed an application for the iPhone and we
are actually using an endoscope coupled with an iPhone to capture video
images. With the video images, we get hundreds of images, not just one image.
If there is a little wax occluding on one area, we can view the next images it will
allow us to do that. Reapplying all those features to those video segments that
we're collecting now, and hope to incorporate it into a grant we're submitting to
DCD, Deafness and Communication Disorders Institute, looking at clinical
decisions supporting the emergency department and the pediatrician office to
actually look at can we aid in the diagnosis of acute otitis media by providing the
Carolyn Coyne: How does this sort of misdiagnosis occur? Is it sort of a lack of understanding of
the diagnosis, of the definition, how does that come about?
Alejandro Hoberman: I think it has to do with the misdiagnosis is generally in babies. It's not in a five
year old complaining of ear pain, those are easy. If you can see the ear drum
and the wax is out of the way and you can visualize the ear drum, the five year
old is simple. The baby is a moving target, so you have cerumen in small ear
canals, cerumen that partially obstructs the ear canal. Then you are relying on
really subtle visual findings that are occur in a brief observation of the ear drum.
I think that's the catch, that sometimes in the most experienced eyes, a brief
observation may be all that you need. Not everybody is at that level and it's very
hard to get to be really sure that you saw enough of an ear drum to make a
Carolyn Coyne: Especially in a crying infant.
Alejandro Hoberman: Correct. Where sometimes you don't have the best holder, the parents want to
hold their child in their arms and you really know to do a good exam you got to
hold them on the examining table and get somebody to get a grip of the head
and a grip of the arms. [crosstalk 00:13:52] that you're using the right
otoscopes, they have the right bulbs with the right amount of light. Once we get
old we start needing reading glasses so we need to switch to otoscopes that
have double dioctors so you canBrian Martin: With all these things it makes 80% accuracy sound likeAlejandro Hoberman: Correct.
Carolyn Coyne: Pretty good, pretty darn good.
Brian Martin: Pretty good. Do you see Alejandro, do you see any role with the emerging
technology focus here on the diagnostic side for this to also aid in shared
decision making and communication with patients and their families in regard to
the situation? The reason I ask is because if we think about the retail medicine
trend and consumerism in medicine, for example, in my clinical world
sometimes people show up with a Google diagnosis in their head that they've
done at home and they have made the decision that they want X, they want an
antibiotic, or they want a particular prescription. Any thoughts on how this
could also assist in talking or do you ever find we have to talk parents out of
antibiotic therapy, if it's an otitis media with effusion where we don't have an
indication for antimicrobial.
Alejandro Hoberman: Absolutely, yes, and I think it has to do with purpose too. It's on the parent side
and the trainee side as well, so you get tool that makes it easier on the parents
and the children because you can go in with a device like this with the
application on the endoscope, you can capture a segment of video and then
nobody has to go in to look at the child again, you have the video to discuss with
the trainees what to consult with somebody else or to use it in telemedicine
application if you need help.
Alejandro Hoberman: We're deploying actually in three offices: one at South Hills in the South Hills of
Pittsburgh, another one in Pennsylvania at a rural qualified health center, and
then one in the north in Cranberry, Pennsylvania, and we have it at the primary
care center with us as well. We're deploying these and we're using them for
training purposes and we're using it for parent's purposes too, where the parent
can see what the ear drum looks like and we can justify here is why we need to
use antibiotics. This is an abnormal ear drum, this is the bulginess, and this is
what we want to try to make better. In contrast when it's completely normal
and the parent wants antibiotics, we can say this is why we don't want to use
antibiotics because when it becomes infected like this one, let me show you a
picture of what represents a video of an ear infection, when it looks like this
then I want the antibiotics to work. The parents are very responsive to that
Carolyn Coyne: Yes, as a parent I would love that. I'm probably a pain in my pediatrician's
because I always want an answer to why, what virus is it, what is it? As you were
talking about before about the bulging ear drum, is that I mentioned my son is
sitting at home with an ear infection. I've never seen what that looks like and so
for me that would actually help me understand a lot of the symptoms and the
causes and perhaps because I tend to be a little more scientific and thinking,
that would be a wonderful asset and tool to have. Talking about the parents,
compliance, this idea of again antibiotic resistance emerging because as you
said before you should very nicely that you needed a 10 day course of
antibiotics to sort of get maximum effect. What do you tell people who aren't
compliant to that, after two or three days fever comes down, symptoms go
away, the parent may say to themselves "oh I don't need to keep dosing, why
do I need to keep giving an antibiotic clearly the symptoms have gone away."
What do you see as ways to address that or the potential problems that that
Alejandro Hoberman: We generally share the fact that we do have the data of the 10 day
improvement over five days of treatment. We even did another study recently
in which we are looking reduced concentration of capulin and we actually
looked at kids at seven days to see if can we get in between, can we get
between five and 10 and still accomplish it. We got two observers, myself and
Mary [inaudible 00:17:50], our best nurse practitioner who trains all the
residents by the way and is outstanding at examining ears, to commit ourselves
would we stop treatment at seven days, even though we're not stopping for the
study. Do we have enough improvement that we can stop treatment? The
answer was no. In most children we would continue treatment, 60 some
percent we would continue treatment. We even gave up on the seven days,
which is something the Finnish have used in their studies in older children they
have used seven days of treatment. I was thinking of five, no, maybe seven
maybe eight, but you know, I would just stick to the 10 days.
Carolyn Coyne: Ten days is best.
Alejandro Hoberman: One more thing that is important too, is in the context of the studies that we've
done, we also showed that there was no impact on resistance. In the five versus
10 day study we looked at them over a one year period. Every time they got an
ear infection we treat them with five or 10 days, there was no increase
resistance in the 10 day group.
Alejandro Hoberman: Nasopharyngeal colonization with pneumococcal resistance to penicillin. That
was shocking, I thought they would be more resistant than they were.
Brian Martin: Do we see any resolution to this 18 year drought of new antibiotics? We
sometimes see in popular media are getting concerned about antibiotic
resistance and the bacteria are out stripping our ability to innovate and to
develop new antimicrobials, is there anything on the horizon in regards to
antimicrobial therapy that might be able to strike a middle ground in terms of
duration of therapy? Some parents and children as we know are more difficult
to get medication into than others, is there anything on your radar screen that
might allow us to be shortened or modified in the future?.
Alejandro Hoberman: We are working on a redevelopment of a antimicrobial amoxicillin-clavulanate,
not with the goal of inventing a new antibiotic, we're trying to decrease that
adverse event profile. The most effective antibiotic, amoxicillin-clavulanate,
causes a high proportion of children having diarrhea, high proportion of children
having... babies having diaper dermatitis, parents discontinue treatment in
many instances. They stop for a few days and then restart, which is the worst
thing we can do, but they're having adverse events so we shouldn't blame them
Alejandro Hoberman: What we did was we reduced the clavulanate to less than half of what's in the
current clavulanate and we were able to accomplish from the pharmacokinetic
standpoint to get levels of the area under the curve, the amount of antibiotic
the baby is exposed to, that are only 5% less. Even though we decrease 55% the
amount of clavulanate, we only got a 5% reduction in the area under the curve.
With about a third of the reduction of the diarrhea, reduction of diaper
dermatitis, and a 90% reduction in discontinuation of steady medication. We
had a meeting with the Food and Drug Administration, they're really interesting
in using the minimal amount of drug that is needed to accomplish the goal. The
efficacy was even a little bit better on the open label study that we did. We're
going to do a four month trial for a approval of that drug and labeling with FDA.
We hope to have to have at least one new antibiotic in the years to come on
Brian Martin: Fantastic. That sounds like a win-win. Well, I want to say thank you very much
for joining us today, we had a delightful conversation..
Carolyn Coyne: Thank you for joining us..
Alejandro Hoberman: Thank you..
Brian Martin: Thank you.
Children's Hospital's main campus is located in the Lawrenceville neighborhood. Our main hospital address is:
UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh
One Children’s Hospital Way
4401 Penn Ave.
Pittsburgh, PA 15224
In addition to the main hospital, Children's has many convenient locations in other neighborhoods throughout the greater Pittsburgh region.
With myCHP, you can request appointments, review test results, and more.
For questions about a hospital bill call:
To pay your bill online, please visit UPMC's online bill payment system.
Interested in giving to Children's Hospital? Support the hospital by making a donation online, joining our Heroes in Healing monthly donor program, or visiting our site to learn about the other ways you can give back.